Arthritis in the foot and ankle rarely announces itself with fanfare. It creeps in as a stubborn morning stiffness, a hitch on stairs, or the way a long walk lingers in the joints a day too long. By the time most people seek help, they have already modified their life around the pain. As a foot and ankle bone and joint surgeon practicing in Springfield, I see the same pattern every week: capable people sidelined by joints that no longer cooperate. The good news is that we have a measured, evidence-based path from evaluation to relief, and it doesn’t always end in the operating room.
This guide distills how a foot and ankle specialist sizes up arthritis, where conservative care excels, when surgery makes sense, and what recovery really looks like. The goal is practical: to help you ask sharper questions and to show the trade-offs a seasoned orthopedic foot and ankle surgeon considers for each joint from the big toe to the ankle.
The moving parts: where arthritis strikes and why it behaves differently
Foot and ankle joints are not interchangeable. The ankle joint bears load and permits up-and-down motion, while the subtalar joint beneath it manages side-to-side adaptability on uneven ground. The midfoot joints act like a set of rockers to transfer force, and the great toe joint propels each step. Arthritis behaves differently in each area, so a thoughtful foot and ankle doctor starts with precise mapping.
- Great toe joint (first MTP): Hallux rigidus is the most common arthritic pattern here. People describe pain pushing off, a dorsal bump that rubs in shoes, and a subtle shortening of stride to avoid that last push. A podiatric surgeon or orthopedic foot specialist will often see early wear in runners and workers who kneel or squat frequently. Midfoot (tarsometatarsal and naviculocuneiform joints): Often post-traumatic or linked to ligamentous laxity, midfoot arthritis shows up as dorsal aching that worsens with standing or hills. The swelling is telling. I palpate across each joint line because tenderness localizes the culprit better than any single image. Hindfoot (subtalar and talonavicular joints): Prior ankle sprains, subtalar coalition, or inflammatory conditions like rheumatoid arthritis can drive this pain. Patients struggle on uneven surfaces, sand, or grass. A foot and ankle orthopedist looks here when the complaint is instability plus deep hindfoot ache. Ankle (tibiotalar joint): Usually post-traumatic from prior fractures or repeated sprains, less often primary degenerative. Ankle arthritis announces itself with predictable swelling at day’s end and pain that improves on a bike but flares after hills. An orthopedic ankle specialist weights the options of joint preservation, fusion, or ankle joint replacement based on alignment, bone stock, and activity goals.
Understanding which joint hurts informs the playbook. A foot and ankle pain doctor who listens to your story and then tests specific motions will often identify the pain generator before the X-ray confirms it.
The first appointment: what a focused evaluation looks like
A thorough exam from a foot and ankle orthopedic doctor starts with the simple act of watching you walk. We study stride length, heel-to-toe transition, and how the foot handles loading. Swelling patterns at the end of the day or after activity narrow the list. I inspect skin, look for callus patterns that reveal offloading, and take ankle and foot through specific arcs of motion to isolate joint pain from tendon pain.
Plain weight-bearing radiographs remain the backbone. They show joint space, osteophytes, cysts, and alignment under real load, which matters more than a non-weight-bearing view. Advanced imaging has a place but is selective. For midfoot or subtalar arthritis, CT can map joint surfaces. For ankle cartilage injuries or suspected osteochondral defects, MRI clarifies the soft tissue and bone marrow response. A diagnostic injection, guided by ultrasound or fluoroscopy, can pinpoint the guilty joint when symptoms overlap.
The workup is not about finding every abnormality. Many people have incidental spurs or old injuries that do not correlate with pain. The foot and ankle consultant’s job is to match images to symptoms and function.
Building a conservative plan that actually changes pain
Most patients with arthritis in the foot or ankle do not need surgery right away. A board certified foot and ankle surgeon should be as comfortable prescribing nonoperative care as operating. The key is to layer interventions that complement one another rather than throwing a long list at the wall.
Footwear and orthoses come first. Shoes with a rocker bottom reduce the need for big toe dorsiflexion and temper midfoot bending. A stiff-soled shoe decreases painful joint motion without making the foot feel trapped. For the ankle, a slightly higher cuff with a firm heel counter can add stability. Custom orthotics or carefully chosen over-the-counter inserts can redistribute pressure, especially for midfoot arthritis or hallux rigidus. I tweak them to offload the sore joint line, not to create a perfect arch.
Targeted physical therapy matters. Range and strength work must respect the arthritic joint. For ankle arthritis, we prioritize gastrocnemius stretching, proprioception, and peroneal strength to improve joint mechanics. For hallux rigidus, we encourage toe flexion strength and limit painful end-range extension while we experiment with shoe modifications. Good therapists in Springfield understand the cadence of load and deload across a week, and they teach patients how to keep progress once formal visits end.
Medications are tools, not bandaids. Topical NSAIDs can make a real difference for superficial joints like the first MTP with a lower systemic burden. Oral NSAIDs help in short courses for flares. Acetaminophen supports background pain control. I reserve corticosteroid injections for targeted relief when inflammation dominates and function is blocked, not as a monthly crutch. A well-placed injection into the ankle or subtalar joint can unlock therapy for 4 to 12 weeks, but we limit frequency to protect cartilage and soft tissue integrity.
Activity modification does not mean surrender. Cycling in place of hills, pool running, and strength training that avoids painful joint angles keep people fit while the inflamed joint calms. A foot and ankle care specialist should point you toward what you still can do, then build from there.
Realistically, a good conservative plan aims for a 30 to 70 percent improvement in pain over 6 to 12 weeks. If we cannot move the needle with the right shoes, therapy, and medication, or if function remains limited by instability or deformity, we start a candid conversation about surgical options.
When surgery earns its place
Operating is not failure. It is a choice when pain, deformity, or loss of function outweighs the risks and recovery. An experienced foot and ankle orthopedic specialist matches procedures to the specific joint, the quality of surrounding tissue, alignment, and the patient’s goals. Here are the options I discuss most often, along with the trade-offs borne out in practice.
Great toe arthritis, or hallux rigidus, has a stepwise surgical ladder. Cheilectomy removes dorsal bone spurs to restore motion when the joint still has preserved cartilage in the central zone. It is often an outpatient procedure, sometimes through a minimally invasive technique for carefully selected cases. Expect improvement in upward motion and relief of shoe irritation. When cartilage loss is advanced and pain persists at mid-range, a fusion becomes the most reliable operation. A foot fusion surgeon sets the toe at a functional angle for walking and balancing. Patients worry about losing motion, yet most report they can hike, ride a bike, and even jog short distances comfortably after fusion because the pain, not the motion, was limiting them. Implant arthroplasty options exist but have mixed durability in active patients. I use them selectively.
Midfoot arthritis responds best to targeted fusion when pain localizes to one or two joints and alignment is good. A foot and ankle reconstructive surgeon prepares the joint surfaces, corrects any subtle deformity, and uses plates and screws to hold the fusion. The trade-off is straightforward: less motion in a stiff segment that already moved poorly, in exchange for pain relief. The challenge is getting weight-bearing right during healing. I tell patients to expect 8 to 12 weeks before transitioning out of a boot, and a full year before the foot forgets it had surgery. Good outcomes hinge on smart procedure selection, meticulous joint preparation, and a patient who understands the pace of bone healing.
Hindfoot arthritis often lives in the subtalar joint or involves multiple joints in a pattern known as triple arthritis. When one joint dominates, an isolated subtalar fusion can preserve neighboring motion. If the talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joints are also involved, a double or triple fusion is more honest. The foot becomes stiffer, but pain decreases and uneven ground becomes manageable again. Experienced foot and ankle reconstruction specialists watch alignment carefully. A few degrees of under or overcorrection can haunt an otherwise solid fusion, which is why preoperative planning with weight-bearing imaging and, sometimes, standing CT makes a difference.
Ankle arthritis is its own arena. The major surgical choices are ankle fusion and total ankle replacement. Fusion is time-tested, especially in physically demanding patients with severe deformity, poor bone stock, or compromised soft tissue. It reliably eliminates joint pain but passes some motion and load to adjacent joints. Over 10 to 15 years, those joints can develop arthritis, though the pace varies with alignment and activity. Total ankle replacement preserves motion, unloads adjacent joints, and increasingly matches fusion for pain relief in the right candidates. Good candidates typically have well-aligned ankles or correctable deformity, decent bone quality, and controlled body weight. A foot and ankle joint surgeon who performs both procedures will walk through lifestyle, goals, and the long view. I frequently advise replacement for active walkers over 55 who value preserved motion and do not plan on heavy-impact sports, and fusion for patients with severe deformity, neuropathy, or occupations that demand repetitive heavy lifting on uneven ground.
Arthroscopy has a role across the foot and ankle when mechanical impingement or focal cartilage lesions dominate. An ankle arthroscopy surgeon can remove inflamed synovium, smooth osteophytes, and treat discrete cartilage defects in selected cases. Arthroscopy can also help diagnose when imaging is equivocal and exam suggests a mechanical block. Its value rests on careful patient selection, not on the small incisions alone.
Minimally invasive techniques exist for bunion correction and some spur removals around the forefoot and hindfoot. A minimally invasive foot surgeon uses specialized burrs through tiny cuts, which can reduce soft tissue trauma and swelling in well-chosen cases. It is not a free pass. The same rules of alignment and fixation quality apply, and safety comes first.
How Springfield patients navigate the decision
A Springfield patient I met this spring, a 62-year-old electrician with ankle arthritis, had tried bracing, an injection, and dedicated therapy. He still lost an hour each workday to pain breaks and worried about ladder safety. His imaging showed moderate varus tilt of the ankle and preserved subtalar joint. We modeled two paths: ankle fusion with a predictable healing arc and certain stiffness, or total ankle replacement with alignment correction and motion preservation. His job involved kneeling and crouching, not constant jumping or running. He chose replacement. Three months later, he was back on light duty. At six months, he was back to full days with a brace for ladder work. He tells me the difference is how comfortably he can pace a full day, and he values that motion when crouching on job sites.
Not every story ends with replacement. A retired postal worker from east Springfield had long-standing hindfoot arthritis after an old fracture. His subtalar joint was the pain driver and the talonavicular joint had mild wear. He could not tolerate uneven ground and limped by noon each day. We chose an isolated subtalar fusion, preserving neighboring joints. Two years out, he hikes Springfield Conservation Nature Center trails again, with a stiffer foot but no limp or afternoon ache.
The point is not that a particular procedure is magic. It is that a foot and ankle orthopedic surgeon who treats the region every day weighs the anatomy, the job, the hobbies, and the risk tolerance. Then we choose the operation that solves the specific problem while protecting your future options.
Recovery, measured honestly
Recovery timetables vary by joint and procedure, yet there are dependable ranges. After cheilectomy for hallux rigidus, many patients are in a postoperative shoe for 2 to 4 weeks, swelling for several months, and steady gain in comfort with push-off by 8 to 12 weeks. After fusion of the first MTP, protected weight-bearing becomes the rule until early bone bridging is seen, often 6 to 8 weeks, and then gradual transition to regular shoes with a rocker sole by three months.
Midfoot fusions demand patience. I explain that we typically protect weight for 6 to 8 weeks, then step-up weight-bearing in a boot across the next month. At 3 to 4 months, many are in a stable shoe, and function improves for 9 to 12 months as the foot adapts.
" width="560" height="315" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen="" >
Subtalar and find ankle surgeon near me hindfoot fusions follow a similar theme, with strict protection early, followed by a deliberate progression. Some patients use a cane for balance on uneven ground for a few months after boot weaning.
Ankle fusion often means 8 to 10 weeks of non-weight-bearing or partial weight with a scooter or crutches, depending on fixation robustness and bone quality. After that, we build weight-bearing cautiously across 4 to 6 weeks. By six months, many people no longer think about stairs. By a year, the fusion feels like the new normal.
Total ankle replacement has its own arc. Early motion within a protective boot starts sooner, and weight-bearing often begins earlier than fusion, though this depends on the exact implant and soft tissue status. Physical therapy focuses on restoring motion, balance, and gait efficiency. Swelling lingers for months and is not a failure. Most patients report their biggest jump in satisfaction between three and six months, then a steady climb through the first year.
Complications exist. Delayed union after fusions, nerve irritation around incisions, wound healing challenges in smokers or those with vascular disease, and the rare deep infection all require vigilance. A foot and ankle trauma surgeon’s training includes managing these issues, but prevention is better. We screen for diabetes control, optimize nutrition, and insist on tobacco cessation before elective surgery. Honest planning reduces surprises.
Role clarity: who does what in foot and ankle care
Patients often ask if they need an orthopedic foot and ankle surgeon or a podiatric foot surgeon. In practice, Springfield benefits from both. A foot and ankle orthopaedic surgeon trains through orthopedic surgery residency then subspecializes in foot and ankle reconstruction, joint replacement, and complex fractures. A podiatrist surgeon trains through podiatric medical school and residency with deep exposure to forefoot and midfoot surgery, biomechanics, and soft tissue care. Many cases sit in the overlap, and collaboration is common. Complex ankle arthritis, malunited fractures, and multi-joint reconstructions typically land with an orthopedic ankle specialist or foot and ankle reconstructive surgeon with implant and fusion expertise. Soft tissue tendon repairs, forefoot corrections, and some arthroscopy cases may be led by a podiatric foot surgeon or an orthopedic foot specialist depending on the surgeon’s experience.
The credential you want to ask about is experience with your specific problem. If you need an ankle ligament repair surgeon with high-volume arthroscopy, ask directly. If you are considering a total ankle, look for an ankle joint replacement surgeon who performs the operation regularly, manages revisions, and can also do a fusion if intraoperative findings dictate. Board certification and fellowship training are helpful signals. Volume and outcomes matter more.
Arthritis and alignment: small angles, big consequences
Alignment steers load. A 5 to 10 degree varus ankle drives wear to the inside of the joint. Flatfoot drives stress to the talonavicular and subtalar joints, while a high arch concentrates pressure under the lateral midfoot and first MTP. An experienced foot and ankle correction specialist evaluates alignment chain-wide, from hip rotation to tibial torsion to hindfoot position. The fix may be as simple as a medial post in an orthotic or as complex as a calcaneal osteotomy added to a fusion to center the heel beneath the leg.
Ignoring alignment during surgery invites early failure. I have revised a handful of fusions done elsewhere where the joint was solid but the heel sat too far in varus, loading the lateral column relentlessly. A small additional osteotomy brought the heel under the leg and the pain settled. This is one reason to seek a foot and ankle revision surgeon if prior surgery did not deliver relief. The problem is not always nonunion. Sometimes it is geometry.
What about biologics and braces?
Patients hear about platelet-rich plasma and stem cell injections. For degenerative arthritis in the ankle and foot, the current evidence supports symptomatic relief in some cases but not structural reversal. I reserve biologics for tendon issues and early cartilage lesions more than established bone-on-bone arthritis. If a treatment cannot be tied to improved function and consistent relief beyond placebo in solid studies, I explain the uncertainty and costs so patients can decide without hype.
Bracing, on the other hand, has dependable value. An ankle lacer, a custom Arizona brace, or a carbon fiber AFO can reduce painful motion and add stability. For a patient not ready for surgery, or one with medical risks that make surgery unwise, these devices preserve mobility and independence. A foot and ankle healthcare provider who works closely with skilled orthotists will get better results.
Preparing for a strong surgical outcome
Operate when ready, not when rushed. Before a fusion or replacement, I ask patients to practice the mobility plan they will need afterward. Try the knee scooter at home, learn to navigate stairs with crutches, and stage sleeping and cooking spaces so you do not live at the edge of your strength for the first two weeks. Address dental care beforehand to reduce infection risk. If you smoke, stop and allow time for physiology to recover. If you are a caregiver for someone else, arrange help. Recovery becomes a lot smoother when the home is set up for success.
Short, clear checklists help here, so this is one of the rare moments a concise list earns its keep.
- Confirm home setup for safe mobility: clear paths, shower chair, handrails if needed, and a downstairs sleeping option for the first weeks. Obtain equipment early: knee scooter, crutches or walker, and a waterproof cast cover if appropriate. Coordinate time off work and arrange a driver for the first appointments postoperatively. Prepare freezer meals and set up medication reminders to avoid missed doses in the first days. Stop nicotine products, optimize diabetes control, and review all supplements with your surgeon to reduce bleeding and wound issues.
Measuring success the way patients feel it
Success is not only an X-ray or a range of motion number. For a runner turned avid hiker, walking Ozark trails again without thinking about every footfall means more than a degree count. For a teacher who stands all day, finishing the last class without wincing matters. A foot and ankle treatment doctor tracks both the objective and the lived. We use validated scales like FAAM or PROMIS to quantify function, yet I also ask about the end of your day, the pace of your morning, and the return of small pleasures like mowing the lawn without swelling.
In clinic, one Springfield patient kept a simple ledger: steps per day and an evening pain score from 0 to 10, four days a week. After his subtalar fusion, the steps doubled by month four and evening pain fell from 7 to 2. He brought the notebook to each visit, and together we adjusted therapy pacing and shoe choices. Small, concrete measures make the process feel navigable.
Finding the right foot and ankle partner in Springfield
Springfield has a healthy ecosystem of care: orthopedic practices with fellowship-trained foot and ankle doctors, experienced podiatric surgeons, skilled physical therapists, and orthotists who understand the demands of our region’s jobs and hobbies. When you meet a prospective ankle and foot doctor, ask how often they treat your condition, what the nonoperative roadmap looks like, and what numbers they use to judge success. If you are considering a complex operation such as a total ankle, hindfoot reconstruction, or multi-joint fusion, it is reasonable to ask for a second opinion. A thoughtful foot and ankle consultant welcomes that and helps you compare approaches.
Titles vary. You may see foot and ankle orthopedist, orthopedic doctor for ankle, foot and ankle physician, or foot and ankle orthopedic specialist, as well as podiatrist surgeon or orthopedic podiatric surgeon. The label matters less than the experience mix and communication style. You want someone who will talk trade-offs, not promises. If the plan includes minimally invasive techniques, ask what happens if intraoperative findings require conversion to an open approach. If you are offered ankle arthroscopy for arthritis, ask what the target is: synovitis, impingement, or focal lesions. If you discuss fusion, ask which joints are included, how alignment is set, and what the plan is if bone heals slowly.
Living well with or without surgery
Not every arthritic joint needs an operation. Many patients settle into a comfortable routine with well-chosen shoes, inserts, therapy, and occasional injections. Others take the step to a foot and ankle surgery when pain erodes too much of daily life. Both paths deserve respect and the right support. When we decide together, the result feels like your choice, not a procedure that happened to you.
As a foot and ankle replacement specialist and reconstruction surgeon in Springfield, I have learned that the best outcomes flow from straightforward communication. We define the problem, try meaningful conservative care, choose the smallest operation that solves the real issue, and run recovery like a project with milestones. Whether you need a foot repair surgeon for a stubborn great toe, an ankle surgery specialist for a worn tibiotalar joint, or a foot and ankle injury doctor to triage a painful flare, the city has the expertise you need.
Arthritis narrows the world by inches before it takes miles. With a clear plan and the right foot and ankle expert at your side, you can reclaim ground, step by step, until the joint fades into the background of a day well spent.